Uptake Post #10

  In the past I have had many experiences with peer review, especially in high school. When I consider peer review I almost always think of essays because no other assignment or project in school ever really seems to require it. After writing essays (draft or full) two students would switch their essays, read the other person’s writing, and give constructive criticism in response. This process is done to get an outsider’s perspective, because it leads to being less biased and sometimes you can not always catch your own mistakes. I would describe a “helpful” peer review as two students who care about their writing giving each other genuinely helpful responses in order to better both of their essays. If one of them does not care or cares significantly less than the other one then it will most likely not be a helpful peer review process. After the process of the review itself the original writers must edit their drafts based on the feedback they have received, otherwise it will also not be a very helpful experience. The peer reviewer specifically should give pointers on grammar mistakes, spelling errors, and similar issues as well as possibly giving insight into the overall tone of the piece if the writer seems to be off for some reason. In response to getting this review, the original writers should read it, and edit their draft accordingly whether they need to use a different word to make it flow better or change some sort of spelling error. In the end the entire idea of peer review only works if the writer does take the criticism into mind and acts accordingly.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Uptake Post #1

      Uptake is loosely defined in the article, "A Great British Baking Adventure: Antecedent Knowledge, My Dog, and a Dry(ish) Cherry Cake" as, "the way we think about new ideas until they make sense to us (ISU Writing Program)." In my own opinion uptake means using your prior knowledge and applying it to new ideas as a way of making sense of the unknown. In our daily lives we use uptake all the time. Every new thing we encounter leads to us using our prior knowledge and skills to make it more familiar or overcome whatever it was. This is an especially helpful skill to be able to use in english because you are constantly reading and writing new and more complex things.
Read more

Uptake Post #3

    As I have been thinking of memories that could be significant enough to tag on my map to represent my writer-research identity, I have specifically been thinking of some of the books I really enjoyed because I am not that much of a big reader.       Whenever I do find a book that I am actually into it is a pretty big deal and I normally tend to get really into it, making it a big part of my literary identity. The two books in this category that I can currently recall are One of Us is Lying by Karen M, McManus and Nerve  by Jeanne Ryan. These two novels controlled my middle school years. I believe I read Nerve  at the end of my sixth grade year; which was technically elementary school for me, but has changed since then. Anyway back on topic, I was obsessed with Nerve for over a year and right when I found that book the movie came out. It was perfect timing and I tortured my family with talking about it. Similarly, my eighth grade year I read ...
Read more

Uptake Post #8

Image
    After doing the reading, I believe translingualism is a special practice or approach to language that views multilingualism not just as the ability to speak languages separately but also as the capacity to navigate and blend them fluidly in communication. A basic example of that is words that sound similar in different languages to the point where two people who might have a total or complete language barrier between each other, can still under stand each other because the words they're using are considered to be translingual. This approach recognizes the dynamic and fluid nature of language, seeing it as a practice of compromising meaning across linguistic boundaries rather than strictly adhering to the rules of any single language. This perspective acknowledges the reality of how people use language in increasingly globalized and culturally diverse settings, where code-switching and hybrid linguistic practices are common. I believe one of the most easy to understan...
Read more